Rare Comics
| What If — 2025 Price Guide Values | #35-47 | ||||||||||
| Issue | Direct Edition Value | CPV Cover Price |
Newsstand Canadian Price Variant Value | CGC-Confirmed | |||||||
| Guide NM- | 9.2 NM- |
9.0 VF/NM |
8.0 VF |
6.0 FN |
4.0 VG |
2.0 GD |
|||||
| #35 |  | $14 | $1.25 | $30 | $26 | $21 | $15 | $10 | $5 | ||
| Marvel, 10/1982 | Conan notes: A CGC 8.5 variant sold at MyComicShop on 2/20/2021 for $26 Doug notes: FIRST Canadian Price Variant in Title; What if Bullseye Had Not Killed Elektra? 16 Page Story by FRANK MILLER with art by FRANK MILLER & Terry Austin; AVENGERS in What if: YELLOW-JACKET had DIED?; CGC label note: Ed Hannigan & Terry Austin cover $1.25 cover price. |
||||||||||
| #36 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $20 | $18 | $14 | $10 | $7 | $3 | ||
| Marvel, 12/1982 | Ben notes: Cover swipe of Fantastic Four #1. Doug notes: What If the Fantastic Four Had Not Gained Their Powers? What If Nova Had Not Given Up His Powers? JOHN BYRNE-c/a; CGC label note: Fantastic Four #1 cover homage. |
||||||||||
| #37 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $32 ▲ $12 |
$28 | $23 | $16 | $11 | $5 | ||
| Marvel, 2/1983 | Doug notes: First appearance of SHALLA BAL as STARGLOW, she gains the POWER COSMIC ** Julia Garner has been cast in the film as a Shalla-Bal version of the SILVER SURFER in The FANTASTIC FOUR Re-Boot Movie will DEBUT on July 25/2025;What If the Thing Had Continues to Mutate? Fantastic Four, Captain America & Giant-Man appear; What If the Beast Had Truly Become a Beast?; What If Galactus Had Turned the Silver Surfer Back Into Norrin Radd? | ||||||||||
| #38 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $20 | $18 | $14 | $10 | $7 | $3 | ||
| Marvel, 4/1983 | Doug notes: Daredevil, Vision and Scarlet Witch, Captain America-c/s; Red Skull, Kingpin appear; CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
||||||||||
| #39 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $30 ▲ $4 |
$26 | $21 | $15 | $10 | $5 | ||
| Marvel, 6/1983 | Conan notes: A raw 6.0 variant sold at MyComicShop on 7/29/2021 for $10 Doug notes: THOR vs CONAN Battle-c/s; |
||||||||||
| #40 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $20 | $18 | $14 | $10 | $7 | $3 | ||
| Marvel, 8/1983 | Doug notes: What If Dr. Strange Had Never Become Master of the Mystic Arts?; Guice-a; | ||||||||||
| #41 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $20 | $18 | $14 | $10 | $7 | $3 | ||
| Marvel, 10/1983 | Doug notes: Sub-Mariner had saved Atlantis from its Destiny? | ||||||||||
| #42 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $20 | $18 | $14 | $10 | $7 | $3 | ||
| Marvel, 12/1983 | Doug notes: What If Susan Richards Died in Childbirth? Fantastic Four-c/s; | ||||||||||
| #43 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $30 | $26 | $21 | $15 | $10 | $5 | ||
| Marvel, 2/1984 | Doug notes: What If CONAN the Barbarian Stranded in 20th Century; Bill Sienkiewicz Painted cover; Doctor Strange, Silver Surfer & Phoenix backup story CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
||||||||||
| #44 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $22 | $19 | $15 | $11 | $7 | $4 | ||
| Marvel, 4/1984 | Doug notes: What If Captain America Were Not Revived Until Today? CGC label note: Fantastic Four, Thor & Avengers appearance. |
||||||||||
| #45 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $30 ▲ $4 |
$26 | $21 | $15 | $10 | $5 | ||
| Marvel, 6/1984 | Doug notes: HULK went Berzerk; Sienkiewicz-c; Fantastic Four & Avengers app; | ||||||||||
| #46 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $26 | $23 | $18 | $13 | $9 | $4 | ||
| Marvel, 8/1984 | Doug notes: What If Spider-Man's Uncle Ben Had Lived? Sienkiewicz-c; Green Goblin appear; CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
||||||||||
| #47 |  | $6 | $1.25 | $36 | $32 | $25 | $18 | $12 | $6 | ||
| Marvel, 10/1984 | Final Issue Doug notes: Scarcer LAST issue; What If Loki Found Thor's Hammer First? Sienkiewicz-c; Kelley Jones-a; CGC label note: Last issue. $1.25 cover price. |
||||||||||
| Issue | Guide NM- | CPV Cover Price |
9.2 NM- |
9.0 VF/NM |
8.0 VF |
6.0 FN |
4.0 VG |
2.0 GD |
CGC-Confirmed | ||
| Direct Edition Value | Newsstand Canadian Price Variant Value | ||||||||||
 | ||||||
| What If CGC Census Changes: | ||||||
| Issue # |
10/3/2023 Census Count |
10/8/2024 Census Count |
Year over year change |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | |
| 35 | 401 | 12 | 419 | 12 | +18 | -- |
| 36 | 98 | 3 | 111 | 4 | +13 | +1 |
| 37 | 53 | -- | 66 | -- | +13 | -- |
| 38 | 42 | 1 | 43 | 1 | +1 | -- |
| 39 | 78 | 1 | 88 | 1 | +10 | -- |
| 40 | 59 | -- | 63 | -- | +4 | -- |
| 41 | 27 | -- | 29 | -- | +2 | -- |
| 42 | 38 | -- | 43 | -- | +5 | -- |
| 43 | 80 | 2 | 88 | 2 | +8 | -- |
| 44 | 31 | -- | 36 | -- | +5 | -- |
| 45 | 62 | -- | 78 | -- | +16 | -- |
| 46 | 46 | 2 | 50 | 2 | +4 | -- |
| 47 | 106 | 2 | 120 | 3 | +14 | +1 |
| Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | |
|
Title Totals: % regular / % variant |
1,121 ~98% |
23 ~2% |
1,234 ~98% |
25 ~2% |
+113 ~98% |
+2 ~2% |
 | ||||||
| Issue | CPV Cover Price |
CPV Value 9.2 |
CGC-Confirmed | |
| #35 | |
$1.25 | $30 | |
| Marvel, 10/1982 | Conan notes: A CGC 8.5 variant sold at MyComicShop on 2/20/2021 for $26 Doug notes: FIRST Canadian Price Variant in Title; What if Bullseye Had Not Killed Elektra? 16 Page Story by FRANK MILLER with art by FRANK MILLER & Terry Austin; AVENGERS in What if: YELLOW-JACKET had DIED?; CGC label note: Ed Hannigan & Terry Austin cover $1.25 cover price. |
|||
| #36 | |
$1.25 | $20 | |
| Marvel, 12/1982 | Ben notes: Cover swipe of Fantastic Four #1. Doug notes: What If the Fantastic Four Had Not Gained Their Powers? What If Nova Had Not Given Up His Powers? JOHN BYRNE-c/a; CGC label note: Fantastic Four #1 cover homage. |
|||
| #37 | |
$1.25 | $32 ▲ $12 |
|
| Marvel, 2/1983 | Doug notes: First appearance of SHALLA BAL as STARGLOW, she gains the POWER COSMIC ** Julia Garner has been cast in the film as a Shalla-Bal version of the SILVER SURFER in The FANTASTIC FOUR Re-Boot Movie will DEBUT on July 25/2025;What If the Thing Had Continues to Mutate? Fantastic Four, Captain America & Giant-Man appear; What If the Beast Had Truly Become a Beast?; What If Galactus Had Turned the Silver Surfer Back Into Norrin Radd? | |||
| #38 | |
$1.25 | $20 | |
| Marvel, 4/1983 | Doug notes: Daredevil, Vision and Scarlet Witch, Captain America-c/s; Red Skull, Kingpin appear; CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
|||
| #39 | |
$1.25 | $30 ▲ $4 |
|
| Marvel, 6/1983 | Conan notes: A raw 6.0 variant sold at MyComicShop on 7/29/2021 for $10 Doug notes: THOR vs CONAN Battle-c/s; |
|||
| #40 | |
$1.25 | $20 | |
| Marvel, 8/1983 | Doug notes: What If Dr. Strange Had Never Become Master of the Mystic Arts?; Guice-a; | |||
| #41 | |
$1.25 | $20 | |
| Marvel, 10/1983 | Doug notes: Sub-Mariner had saved Atlantis from its Destiny? | |||
| #42 | |
$1.25 | $20 | |
| Marvel, 12/1983 | Doug notes: What If Susan Richards Died in Childbirth? Fantastic Four-c/s; | |||
| #43 | |
$1.25 | $30 | |
| Marvel, 2/1984 | Doug notes: What If CONAN the Barbarian Stranded in 20th Century; Bill Sienkiewicz Painted cover; Doctor Strange, Silver Surfer & Phoenix backup story CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
|||
| #44 | |
$1.25 | $22 | |
| Marvel, 4/1984 | Doug notes: What If Captain America Were Not Revived Until Today? CGC label note: Fantastic Four, Thor & Avengers appearance. |
|||
| #45 | |
$1.25 | $30 ▲ $4 |
|
| Marvel, 6/1984 | Doug notes: HULK went Berzerk; Sienkiewicz-c; Fantastic Four & Avengers app; | |||
| #46 | |
$1.25 | $26 | |
| Marvel, 8/1984 | Doug notes: What If Spider-Man's Uncle Ben Had Lived? Sienkiewicz-c; Green Goblin appear; CGC label note: $1.25 cover price. |
|||
| #47 | |
$1.25 | $36 | |
| Marvel, 10/1984 | Final Issue Doug notes: Scarcer LAST issue; What If Loki Found Thor's Hammer First? Sienkiewicz-c; Kelley Jones-a; CGC label note: Last issue. $1.25 cover price. |
|||
| Issue | CPV Cover Price |
CPV Value 9.2 |
CGC-Confirmed | |
| ||||
| What If CGC Census Data: | ||||
| Issue # |
10/8/2024 Census Count |
Year over year change |
||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | |
| 35 | 419 | 12 | +18 | -- |
| 36 | 111 | 4 | +13 | +1 |
| 37 | 66 | -- | +13 | -- |
| 38 | 43 | 1 | +1 | -- |
| 39 | 88 | 1 | +10 | -- |
| 40 | 63 | -- | +4 | -- |
| 41 | 29 | -- | +2 | -- |
| 42 | 43 | -- | +5 | -- |
| 43 | 88 | 2 | +8 | -- |
| 44 | 36 | -- | +5 | -- |
| 45 | 78 | -- | +16 | -- |
| 46 | 50 | 2 | +4 | -- |
| 47 | 120 | 3 | +14 | +1 |
| Regular | Variant | Regular | Variant | |
|
Title Totals: % regular / % variant |
1,234 ~98% |
25 ~2% |
+113 ~98% |
+2 ~2% |
| ||||
